Skip to content
CCold Email Tools

We may earn a commission if you sign up through links on this page. This does not affect scores. How we make money

Instantly vs Mailshake

Instantly scores 68.1/100 (6th of 10) and Mailshake scores 63.7/100 (8th) in our ranking of cold email tools. Both are scored on the same 7 criteria, from public, dated sources.

Data checked on November 21, 2026 · Re-checked monthly · Methodology

Score, criterion by criterion

CriterionInstantlyMailshake
Sending and deliverability /2518.812.5
Campaign features /201214
Channels and lead data /153.811.3
Integrations and API /10108.8
Team and agency features /52.50
Pricing access /128.55
User reviews /1312.512.1
Total68.1/10063.7/100

Profile, pricing, and capabilities

InstantlyMailshake
TypeCold email platformCold email platform
ChannelsEmailEmail, Calls
PricingFrom $47 per monthFrom $29 per user per month
Pricing modelFlat rate, Usage-basedPer user
Free planNot statedNot stated
Free trialYesNot stated
User reviews4.8/5 on G2 (4,134 reviews)4.7/5 on G2 (374 reviews) · 4.6/5 on Capterra (161 reviews)
Unlimited email accountsYesNot stated
Built-in email warm-upYesYes
Inbox rotationYesYes
Unified inboxYesYes
A/B testingYesYes
SpintaxYesYes
Conditional sequencesYesYes
Built-in email verificationYesYes
Inbox placement testingYesNot stated
Built-in lead databaseYesYes
AI email writingYesYes
Public APIYesYes
Built-in CRMYesNot stated
White label or client workspacesYesNot stated
Domain and mailbox setupYesYes

“Not stated” means the vendor's public pages do not mention it.

Choose Instantly if…

  • Higher score on sending and deliverability: 18.8 against 12.5 out of 25
  • Higher score on integrations and api: 10 against 8.8 out of 10
  • Higher score on team and agency features: 2.5 against 0 out of 5
  • Higher score on pricing access: 8.5 against 5 out of 12
  • Higher score on user reviews: 12.5 against 12.1 out of 13
  • Instantly states unlimited email accounts, inbox placement testing, built-in crm, and white label or client workspaces, which Mailshake does not state
  • More published user reviews: 4,134 against 535

Choose Mailshake if…

  • Higher score on campaign features: 14 against 12 out of 20
  • Higher score on channels and lead data: 11.3 against 3.8 out of 15
  • You need Calls steps in your sequences
  • Lower published starting price: $29 against $47 per month (plans differ in what they include)

Instantly vs Mailshake: frequently asked questions

What is the difference between Instantly and Mailshake?

Instantly is a cold email platform that ranks 6th of 10 with 68.1/100. Mailshake is a cold email platform that ranks 8th with 63.7/100. The gap is 4.4 points out of 100.

Where does Mailshake beat Instantly?

Mailshake scores higher on campaign features (14 against 12) and channels and lead data (11.3 against 3.8).

How much do Instantly and Mailshake cost?

Instantly: From $47 per month. Mailshake: From $29 per user per month.

How are these scores computed?

Both tools are scored with the same public method: 7 criteria and 100 points (Sending and deliverability 25, Campaign features 20, Channels and lead data 15, Integrations and API 10, Team and agency features 5, Pricing access 12, User reviews 13). Each point is tied to a public source listed on the tool's page. Affiliate relationships do not affect scores.

More comparisons